• Air date: 08 Jan '20 95 episodes
      In each episode, with the guidance and help of Nev Schulman and Max Joseph, a hopeful romantic partner will go on an emotional journey to discover the truth about their significant other. Has that object of affection been telling the truth?
  • List of Episodes (95)
    • 76. Angela & Justin

      21 Mar '23
      After splitting from her husband of 20 years, Angela reinvented herself and is excited by her new TikTok love interest Justin; he's been dodgy about meeting, but she's ready for something real.
    • 77. Sham & Phillip

      28 Mar '23
      Sham has been swept off her feet by an Instagram Arab prince named Phillip, but lately Phillip's been acting shady.
    • 78. Jaquan & Shantel

      04 Apr '23
      Content creator Jaquan has yet to meet his online flame and Rochester, NY, neighbor Shantel, but his social media antics make Nev and Kamie think his case is little fishier than usual.
    • 79. Erika & Jermaine

      11 Apr '23
      Erika fell in love with Jermaine as he supported her through the toughest time in her life, but after 3 years of dating he’s remained cagey about meeting. Can Nev and Kamie help Erika uncover the secret Jermaine has been hiding?
    • 80. Jacob & Stephanie

      18 Apr '23
      Jacob’s tough life turned bright the day Stephanie popped into his livestream. Now, with all his hopes hanging on Stephanie, Nēv and Kamie struggle with an impossible decision as they fear Stephanie may be too good to be true!
    • 81. William & Carmella

      25 Apr '23
      William's connection with Carmella is undeniably strong, but after three months of dodging his attempts to meet, William calls on Nēv and Kamie to find out what Carmella's hiding. Season Finale.
    • 82. Shi & Mira

      03 Oct '23
      Shi is convinced his online love Mira also lives in Philadelphia, but after months, she’s dodgy about meeting. When Nev and Kamie discover she might live just five blocks away, they hit the streets of Philly looking for answers!
    • 83. Cody & Brittany

      10 Oct '23
      Cody's concerned grandmother needs Nev and Kamie's help hunting down Brittany, a woman Cody claims he met in real life, is deeply in love with, and has sent thousands of dollars.
    • 84. Jasmine & Ryan

      17 Oct '23
      Jasmine has dealt with hardships and loss at every step of her life until she met Ryan, and while he seems to be perfect, his excuses on why he cannot meet have Nev and Kamie questioning him.
    • 85. Tee and Ibraheem

      24 Oct '23
      Tee and Ibraheem are so deeply in love that Ibraheem decided to get a neck tattoo of her name. The only problem-Tee lied about her name when they first met! If Ibraheem and his tattoo are real, will their love survive the fallout?
    • 86. Matt & Elise

      31 Oct '23
      Matt's smitten with TikToker Elise, but Nev and guest host Devyn Simone see red flags on the horizon. When asked to meet, Elise says she's worried about upsetting Nev! Who is this mystery girl and what's her connection to Nev?! Guest co-host: Devyn Simone
    • 87. Moses & Krystal

      07 Nov '23
      After a tough divorce, Moses found new hope in Krystal. But despite living close by, Krystal won't meet up. The more Nev and Kamie dig into 'Krystal' the more shocked and determined they are to find answers to this bizarre case!
    • 88. Zach & Lexie

      14 Nov '23
      When Zach matched with Lexie, he couldn't believe his luck, but she could be too good to be true.
    • 89. Jass & Kayla 

      21 Nov '23
      After Jass gets a tattoo of Lillian's name, Jass discovers her pictures and name are fake.
    • 90. Eli & Boulevard

      28 Nov '23
      Eli fell so hard for fellow gamer Boulevard, that he moved from Alaska to Chicago to be with her. But when he got there, Boulevard was nowhere to be found! Nev and Laura Perlongo go on a wild ride to help Eli figure out who turned his life upside down.
    • 91. LaDaris & Julie

      05 Dec '23
      Iraq veteran LaDaris has been in love with Julie for years, despite her cancelling plans to meet several times; she has a mysterious twin sister getting in between them, so Nev and Kamie help LaDaris figure things out.
    • 92. Genesis & Jerison

      12 Dec '23
      Comic Percy Rustomji joins Nev in helping Genesis find Jerison, a man she met 12 years ago on Facebook and with whom she recently reconnected.
    • 93. Ciatta & Juan

      19 Dec '23
      Ciatta has a bright family future planned with her perfect man Juan. But before Nev and Kamie give their blessings on Ciatta's move to LA to be with him, they uncover details on Juan that her life plans into question.
    • 94. Sasha & Essence

      26 Dec '23
      Sasha’s been in a wild flirtationship with Essence for years and is ready for the next level. Essence says she’s in an open relationship with her man, but Sasha feels like she is keeping a secret. Can Catfish help Sasha find out what Essence is hiding?
    • 95. Leanna & Jordan

      02 Jan '24
      Leanna fell so hard for Jordan that she sent him thousands of dollars! Though she's never met Jordan in person she did meet his cousin. Armed with only a sketch, Nev and Kamie go on a manhunt searching for the cousin.